@sfender I think you are missing the whole point here. You'll need to eventually use that money because of the obvious reason, old age.
Take this scenario for example:
I'm 60 years old and I have a 100K put in HMAX, that would pay me out about $13k + a year and is enough to cover my expenses if I have to live in a low cost of living area, like in Asia for example. Now, I know that dividends investment loses money overtime, but even if that reduces to half in like 20 years its still money well spent because it pays you for 20 years. Who knows if I'm still alive by that time.
Compare that to
CASH.TO where you only get 5%, which is just 5K a year and is definitely not enough to cover the day to day expenses. Thats not even taking into account inflation.
Its not about losing money, its just about playing it right depending on your situation. So, pick your poison.