US full-time contractor v.s CAD Full-time Employee

@nilz I just recently went through this and I’d rather be tied to CAD as long as your $218k/yr is consistent, who cares what the USD is at. This was a sticking point for them and I had to take the USD salary to be paid in CAD. Economist outlooks don’t look there will be a ton of fluctuation in the near future, but it will be weird getting a different wire amount every 2 weeks.
 
@rita1989 You read that wrong - CAD will be pegged. In other words, it'll be 216K CAD all year long. If USD to CAD goes 1:1, they'll still make 216K CAD vs 160 CAD with option 1.
 
@nilz Incorporate and become a contractor. Make sure you can secure another small contract part time as well. This will help with labeling with the cra. You can basically use the corporation as an rrsp. Make a business account and get a business credit card. Talk to an accountant and start going over on how to limit your taxes on the income you get
 
@galations322 In what way is the corporation an RRSP?

The corporation is the contractor in your scenario, not OP. OP is the director and sole shareholder of the corporation, and still has to file his personal taxes. Keeping in mind as well that OP would need to pay himself from the corporation via a T4 slip (aka still be an employee anyways just to do his own tax deductions) in order to avoid being just as liable for any issues as he would be as a sole proprietor.
 
@galations322 If you take money from the corp via dividends, you are personally liable for tax debt, etc. Doesn’t matter what else you do.

Not to mention that technically any of these ‘contractor’ options would require OP to have a GST account since >$30k/yr in earnings means that you’re a mandatory GST registrant. So now OP has to remit GST as well.
 
@foodie20 GST doesn’t apply to international customers though. I just asked 2 accountants that.

He will be liable for the tax that he takes out. So if he makes 200k and only takes out 50k. He only gets taxed for 50k. That’s how it can be used somewhat like an rrsp
 
@galations322 That still depends on whether or not this employer has a Canadian arm or owns property in Canada. Suppliers don’t have to charge GST on services they perform totally outside of Canada, but whether or not that’s the case for OP depends on other factors too.

We’re talking about 2 different things re: liability. I’m talking about if the corporation doesn’t pay its taxes appropriately/file on time/etc, OP will be personally liable to repay the tax debt of the corporation if they take dividends.
 
@galations322 Yes, but then any money he makes is taxed twice (as corporate income tax, then as his personal income tax). And at that point, why not just be an employee of the actual company you’re working for?
 
@nilz Incorporate and become an independent contractor, you will get full benefit of the currency depreciation.
Take 50k as salary from your corp. Minimum personal tax for you and corp tax only 25% save paying on tax.
This is what I am doing. But talk to your accountant
 
@sugarplum1 But essentially the money is getting taxed twice then. I haven’t done the math on the difference on the net between the two, but that would mean your pay is getting taxed as corporate income via your corporation, then again as personal income tax when you file your return. So not necessarily a slam dunk
 
@foodie20 I think 50k is the minimum where your monthly paychecks will be tax deducted but you will get a handsome refund on your personal income tax return.
On the other hand all the money you did not draw as salary and piling up in your Incorporation bank account gets taxed at a lower 25% corp tax. Plus you being the employee can ask for wifi, insurance, rent reimbursement from your company which show up as expenses (essentially tax free).

So on aggregate you will be taxed at a lower rate than drawing full time salary. At 218 k salary your total taxes will be close 50% of your gross
 

Similar threads

Back
Top